Four bachelors have made picking up women into a trivial game. Then one night the tables are turned and a sultry stranger named Elyse (India Summer) walks into the bar. Brandon (Ryan Driller) quickly realizes that he may have bitten off more than he can chew. Luckily the night ends well and he is the hero among his friends. Growing tired of the player lifestyle, Brandon starts a relationship with the girl of his dreams. All seems to be moving along perfectly until she takes him home to meet her parents and he suddenly finds himself face to face with Elyse again. This time the cougar isn't as willing to let go and will do anything and everything for a round two with her daughter's new boyfriend.